Hasan3 wrote:
> I tested simple  Povray and Yafray scene.
> 
> Antialias:
> Povray settings : AA:0.01 , Yafray :AA:0.05
> Result : Yafray is better than Povray:(
> 
> Light diffusion:
> Povray settings : Brilliance : 4
> Yafray setting : Default
> Result : Yafray is better than Povray:(
> 
> But I like povray. I hope that Povray will develope.
> is this possible?

1) I don't see any indication in those images explaining why you think 
one is 'better'.

2) The major differences between the images most likely result from 
different scenes and render settings and not from differences in the 
renderer abilities.

3) any such comparison that does not include render times does not make 
much sense.

4) You are comparing apples and peaches - Yafray can only render 
triangles while in POV-Ray you can create the cylinders as true 
cylinders (which apparently you have not).

To sum it up: It would be great to see a qualified comparison between 
Yafray and POV-Ray.  Gilles Tran some time ago did this for C4D and 
POV-Ray (using radiosity and antialiasing test scenes and comparing 
program features).  Your two images do not give much useful information 
on this aspect though.

Christoph

-- 
POV-Ray tutorials, include files, Landscape of the week:
http://www.imagico.de/ (Last updated 31 Oct. 2005)
MegaPOV with mechanics simulation: http://megapov.inetart.net/

Post a reply to this message