On 5-3-2009 0:12, Saul Luizaga wrote:
> andrel wrote:
>> On 4-3-2009 17:13, Saul Luizaga wrote:
>>> Warp wrote:
>>>> Darren New <dne### [at] sanrrcom> wrote:
>>>>> Warp wrote:
>>>>>>   "Life on Earth came from other planets", after surviving a 
>>>>>> supernova
>>>>>> explosion and hundreds of millions of years of intestellar space 
>>>>>> travel?
>>>>>>
>>>>>>   Uh, yeah.
>>>>
>>>>> That's why the game is called "spore". :-)
>>>>
>>>>> Isn't this the sort of thing we tease Andrew about, tho? When he 
>>>>> conflates "That's really amazing and I can't imagine how I could do 
>>>>> that" with "it must therefore be impossible"?
>>>>
>>>>   Some kind of proof or even evidence would be nice.
>>>>
>>>
>>>
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ByUod2VmBQY&eurl=http://brainmind.com/OriginsofLife.html

>>>
>>>
>>> good enough?
>>
>> Nope. The guy does not know his basic facts and merely uses a strawman 
>> approach to show off his 'superior intelligence'.
> 
> Then: http://brainmind.com/Mars.html

Sorry, I have not been able to listen to this guy for more than a few 
minutes because of all the uninformed nonsense this guy is telling, so I 
won't try this one.

> 
> You're just criticizing here, 

Yes, deliberately. And I advised you to go out and find the real info.

> not making much sense justifying your 
> point of view, 

yes, deliberately.

> this guy makes *A LOT* more sense than you.

He makes sense in that he is able to construct a consistent story. 
Unfortunately his story mainly consists of attacking other ideas by 
misrepresenting them. He probably could have been a great writer of 
science if he would have read some relevant literature and tried to tell 
what we really know and think in stead of just wanting to tell how he 
thinks things should be.

I don't have much time today but if you want I'll dissect the first 5 
minutes or so of the origins of life video and tell you what is, to the 
best of *my* knowledge, the actual state of knowledge, somewhere over 
the weekend. But of course I'd prefer it if you did your own research. ;)

Post a reply to this message