 |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Alain
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 21 Apr 2011 18:45:49
Message: <4db0b39d$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
Le 2011/04/21 17:14, Jim Henderson a écrit :
> On Thu, 21 Apr 2011 17:12:02 -0400, Warp wrote:
>
>> Orchid XP v8<voi### [at] dev null> wrote:
>>> The title says a revolution is happening. What's the opposite of a
>>> scientific revolution? (Or should we just call it an "America"?)
>>
>> Pseudoscientific revolution?
>
> I wouldn't even give it that much credit. That puts it on par with
> homeopathy. It's even lower than that, because it doesn't even pretend
> to be scientific (homeopathy isn't scientific, but it tries to pretend to
> be).
>
> I'd call it an 'anti-science revolution'.
>
> Jim
How about:
Pretend-science
Moron-science
Jackass-science
Unscience
Take your pick.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: andrel
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 21 Apr 2011 18:46:38
Message: <4DB0B3CD.2070802@gmail.com>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 21-4-2011 7:06, Jim Henderson wrote:
> On Thu, 21 Apr 2011 00:26:31 +0200, andrel wrote:
>
>>> And what is the hypothesis? That a particular protein didn't evolve? Or
>>> that some intelligence actually created that protein?
>>
>> That there are proteins (etc.) that didn't evolve by natural selection.
>> Or even weaker that their presence is easier explained by design than as
>> a result of natural selection. (hijacking Occam's razor).
>
> No, that's not correct. Just because something can't be explained by
> evolution (assuming it were found) doesn't mean ID is how it occurred.
In it's purest form ID does not give an explanation what did happen if
it wasn't evolution.
> What it means is we don't understand the process by which it occurred.
yes
> Leaping to the conclusion that it's ID because it isn't evolution is a
> poor application of Occam's razor (at best) and lazy rationalization (at
> worst).
See above. you are again assuming you know what the alternative should
be. That almost everybody publicly defending ID shares your assumption,
indeed moves them into the camp of easily proven to be non-scientific.
My whole point in defending that ID in the form stated above can be a
scientific hypothesis is that you have to forget about all the people
that claim God did it.
--
Apparently you can afford your own dictator for less than 10 cents per
citizen per day.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 21 Apr 2011 19:16:33
Message: <4db0bad1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/21/2011 15:46, andrel wrote:
> In it's purest form ID does not give an explanation what did happen if it
> wasn't evolution.
Then why is it called "intelligent design" if in its purest form it's not
hypothesizing intelligent design?
> point in defending that ID in the form stated above
I disagree that ID is "some things didn't evolve." That's backing off so far
that one is simply searching hopelessly for anything that's non-disprovable.
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: andrel
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 04:22:55
Message: <4DB13ADE.1040002@gmail.com>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 22-4-2011 1:16, Darren New wrote:
> On 4/21/2011 15:46, andrel wrote:
>> In it's purest form ID does not give an explanation what did happen if it
>> wasn't evolution.
>
> Then why is it called "intelligent design" if in its purest form it's
> not hypothesizing intelligent design?
>
>> point in defending that ID in the form stated above
>
> I disagree that ID is "some things didn't evolve." That's backing off so
> far that one is simply searching hopelessly for anything that's
> non-disprovable.
No, just to the point where it is in principle provable, but in practice
not. If it is non-disprovable it is not science anymore. So you cannot
cross that line.
--
Apparently you can afford your own dictator for less than 10 cents per
citizen per day.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 11:52:06
Message: <4db1a426$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 1:22, andrel wrote:
> On 22-4-2011 1:16, Darren New wrote:
>> On 4/21/2011 15:46, andrel wrote:
>>> In it's purest form ID does not give an explanation what did happen if it
>>> wasn't evolution.
>>
>> Then why is it called "intelligent design" if in its purest form it's
>> not hypothesizing intelligent design?
>>
>>> point in defending that ID in the form stated above
>>
>> I disagree that ID is "some things didn't evolve." That's backing off so
>> far that one is simply searching hopelessly for anything that's
>> non-disprovable.
>
> No, just to the point where it is in principle provable, but in practice
> not.
But nobody has even come up with an idea of how you would show a protein
could not have evolved. "Irreducible complexity" doesn't show a protein
could not have evolved. So how would you recognize such a protein?
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: John VanSickle
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 13:08:33
Message: <4db1b611$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
> But more to the point, who gets to define what is Christian (which was
> the point of asking for an explanation of that statement), as throughout
> history a lot of things are done in Christianity's name - so who gets to
> decide "yes, that's a Christian thing to do" and "no, that's not a
> Christian thing to do and one who does it isn't Christian".
That's not hard. Read the Bible and see what it says about how to
become a Christian, and what it commands Christians to do. Then compare
it to the doings of the religious bodies in question. Time and again,
at so many points of teaching, we find things taught and practiced that
cannot be found in the Bible, from even the very basics of becoming a
Christian, to the organization of the church, liturgy, and so forth.
Getting back to the point at hand: There simply is no command in the
Bible for Christians to kill Jews, to make them second-class citizens,
or to maltreat them in any way. Those claiming to be Christians who did
these things were following another authority.
Regards,
John
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Warp
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 13:50:16
Message: <4db1bfd8@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
John VanSickle <evi### [at] hotmail com> wrote:
> > But more to the point, who gets to define what is Christian (which was
> > the point of asking for an explanation of that statement), as throughout
> > history a lot of things are done in Christianity's name - so who gets to
> > decide "yes, that's a Christian thing to do" and "no, that's not a
> > Christian thing to do and one who does it isn't Christian".
> That's not hard. Read the Bible and see what it says about how to
> become a Christian, and what it commands Christians to do. Then compare
> it to the doings of the religious bodies in question. Time and again,
> at so many points of teaching, we find things taught and practiced that
> cannot be found in the Bible, from even the very basics of becoming a
> Christian, to the organization of the church, liturgy, and so forth.
If it were that simple, there wouldn't be something like 30000 different
denominations of Christianity (if I remember the estimate correctly).
In modern times the interpretation of different denominations is always
colored by what is generally understood as (secular) basic human rights.
In medieval times the Catholic church (and other minor denominations of
the time) had no problem in accepting, for example, the witch killing
statutes of the old testament. Nowadays those statutes are almost globally
dismissed as not applying anymore (the reason varying wildly from
denomination to denomination, and even between individual Christians).
Not because christianity had changed on its own, but because nowadays
the secular notion of basic human rights abhors such statutes, and
christianity has adapted.
Would you say that the Catholic church was not "true christianity" at
the time when it still persecuted witches? Why doesn't it persecute them
nowadays? What has changed?
The thing is, when talking about what is morally right and wrong, the
Bible is a pick-and-choose book. Everybody chooses the passages that
conform to their own sense of morality (often colored by secular notions
of human rights) and dismisses the passages that don't (by using wildly
differing justifications on why the passage in question doesn't hold
anylonger).
--
- Warp
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 14:58:14
Message: <4db1cfc6@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Fri, 22 Apr 2011 13:08:29 -0400, John VanSickle wrote:
>> But more to the point, who gets to define what is Christian (which was
>> the point of asking for an explanation of that statement), as
>> throughout history a lot of things are done in Christianity's name - so
>> who gets to decide "yes, that's a Christian thing to do" and "no,
>> that's not a Christian thing to do and one who does it isn't
>> Christian".
>
> That's not hard. Read the Bible and see what it says about how to
> become a Christian, and what it commands Christians to do. Then compare
> it to the doings of the religious bodies in question. Time and again,
> at so many points of teaching, we find things taught and practiced that
> cannot be found in the Bible, from even the very basics of becoming a
> Christian, to the organization of the church, liturgy, and so forth.
So that's why there's only one sect of Christianity, then? (Oh, wait,
there isn't). So whose interpretation is "correct"?
That's kinda the point, John.
> Getting back to the point at hand: There simply is no command in the
> Bible for Christians to kill Jews, to make them second-class citizens,
> or to maltreat them in any way. Those claiming to be Christians who did
> these things were following another authority.
Maybe not in your interpretation, but I'm sure there are others who
interpret it as being there. So it again comes down to *whose*
interpretation are we using.
Just like with the Qu'ran the question is *whose interpretation* is being
used - the one that says 'kill the infidels' or the one that says 'Islam
is peaceful'.
That's the problem with having a holy book that's used as a 'set of
directions' where it's been translated, re-translated, interpreted, re-
interpreted, and heavily edited over a couple millenia. Not to mention
the books that have been removed over the centuries because they didn't
fit with the politics of the time (or whatever other excuse was given).
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 15:00:45
Message: <4db1d05d$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Fri, 22 Apr 2011 00:46:37 +0200, andrel wrote:
> On 21-4-2011 7:06, Jim Henderson wrote:
>> On Thu, 21 Apr 2011 00:26:31 +0200, andrel wrote:
>>
>>>> And what is the hypothesis? That a particular protein didn't evolve?
>>>> Or that some intelligence actually created that protein?
>>>
>>> That there are proteins (etc.) that didn't evolve by natural
>>> selection. Or even weaker that their presence is easier explained by
>>> design than as a result of natural selection. (hijacking Occam's
>>> razor).
>>
>> No, that's not correct. Just because something can't be explained by
>> evolution (assuming it were found) doesn't mean ID is how it occurred.
>
> In it's purest form ID does not give an explanation what did happen if
> it wasn't evolution.
Um, ID (by its very name) does attempt to explain what happened. "God did
it".
>> What it means is we don't understand the process by which it occurred.
>
> yes
>
>> Leaping to the conclusion that it's ID because it isn't evolution is a
>> poor application of Occam's razor (at best) and lazy rationalization
>> (at worst).
>
> See above. you are again assuming you know what the alternative should
> be. That almost everybody publicly defending ID shares your assumption,
> indeed moves them into the camp of easily proven to be non-scientific.
> My whole point in defending that ID in the form stated above can be a
> scientific hypothesis is that you have to forget about all the people
> that claim God did it.
No, I'm not assuming what the alternative would be. There's a difference
between "God did it" (or more precisely "An intelligent being created us
out of nothing") and "I don't know."
That's what I mean by "it's ID" is lazy - whenever humans have reached
the limits of their current understanding, the default answer for some is
"God did it". Then later, someone discovers, "Wait, it wasn't God, it
was a natural process that we can now explain."
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 15:01:46
Message: <4db1d09a@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Thu, 21 Apr 2011 18:45:49 -0400, Alain wrote:
> Le 2011/04/21 17:14, Jim Henderson a écrit :
>> On Thu, 21 Apr 2011 17:12:02 -0400, Warp wrote:
>>
>>> Orchid XP v8<voi### [at] dev null> wrote:
>>>> The title says a revolution is happening. What's the opposite of a
>>>> scientific revolution? (Or should we just call it an "America"?)
>>>
>>> Pseudoscientific revolution?
>>
>> I wouldn't even give it that much credit. That puts it on par with
>> homeopathy. It's even lower than that, because it doesn't even pretend
>> to be scientific (homeopathy isn't scientific, but it tries to pretend
>> to be).
>>
>> I'd call it an 'anti-science revolution'.
>>
>> Jim
>
> How about:
> Pretend-science
> Moron-science
> Jackass-science
> Unscience
>
> Take your pick.
I like it. :)
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 15:05:20
Message: <4db1d170$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Thu, 21 Apr 2011 18:30:19 -0400, Warp wrote:
> Jim Henderson <nos### [at] nospam com> wrote:
>> I was thinking of something else (but of course I can't remember what
>> now). You are correct that ID does try to pretend to be - I guess I'm
>> having a problem with "scientific" being combined with "religious
>> belief" and that's what led me to say "anti-scientific" - as I see
>> 'religious belief' as being antithetical to 'knowledge'.
>
> The whole idea with the "intelligent design" movement is to mask the
> fact that it's simply repackaged creationism, by removing all mentions
> of "God" and other theistic claims.
Yes, but a rebranding of creationism as "intelligent design" doesn't mean
it's not religiously motivated. I guess for those who don't see through
that deception and who have a very limited understanding of what
scientific discovery actually is might think it was 'an appearance of
science'.
> In the worst case scenario the whole schooling system could get
> sabotaged
> to a catastrophical point. Science, technology and progress would suffer
> enormously.
Yes, and I think ultimately this demonstrates the real danger of this
type of theistic thinking - not to mention that when it enters the public
schools, it violates the establishment clause of the US Constitution. If
a public school is teaching religious theology about the creation of the
universe (whether they use religious metaphors or not), I'm sorry, that's
state-sponsored religion, and that's unconstitutional.
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 15:06:06
Message: <4db1d19e$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Thu, 21 Apr 2011 15:35:20 -0700, Darren New wrote:
> On 4/21/2011 15:30, Warp wrote:
>> start demanding to "teach the controversy" in geography class, and so
>> on.
>
> http://www.joeydevilla.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2008/06/
teach_the_controversy_t-shirt_designs.jpg
>
> I'm sure you've seen that stuff.
I love it. :)
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 16:32:33
Message: <4db1e5e1$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 11:58, Jim Henderson wrote:
> That's the problem with having a holy book that's used as a 'set of
> directions' where it's been translated, re-translated, interpreted, re-
> interpreted, and heavily edited over a couple millenia.
Yeah, except the Qu'an isn't really quite like that. It's all one giant
unambiguous book written by one guy in one lifetime.
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 16:43:33
Message: <4db1e875$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Fri, 22 Apr 2011 13:32:31 -0700, Darren New wrote:
> On 4/22/2011 11:58, Jim Henderson wrote:
>> That's the problem with having a holy book that's used as a 'set of
>> directions' where it's been translated, re-translated, interpreted, re-
>> interpreted, and heavily edited over a couple millenia.
>
> Yeah, except the Qu'an isn't really quite like that. It's all one giant
> unambiguous book written by one guy in one lifetime.
But I think you'll find that it's been interpreted/translated a few times.
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Nekar Xenos
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 17:00:46
Message: <op.vucxziedufxv4h@xena>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Fri, 22 Apr 2011 22:32:31 +0200, Darren New <dne### [at] san rr com> wrote:
> On 4/22/2011 11:58, Jim Henderson wrote:
>> That's the problem with having a holy book that's used as a 'set of
>> directions' where it's been translated, re-translated, interpreted, re-
>> interpreted, and heavily edited over a couple millenia.
>
> Yeah, except the Qu'an isn't really quite like that. It's all one giant
> unambiguous book written by one guy in one lifetime.
>
unambiguous?
http://www.google.co.za/search?client=opera&rls=en&q=ambiguous+quran&sourceid=opera&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8
--
-Nekar Xenos-
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:03:47
Message: <4db1fb43@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/21/2011 3:35 PM, andrel wrote:
>> ID's central premise, sadly, is that it just "poofed" into being. Hell,
>> even the ones arguing "front loading", fail to grasp that any such
>> "master genetic code", to avoid breaking the organism fatally, while
>> inserting new features, has to take clear steps, in which it replaces
>> parts of the system, only as possible, before reaching and end result.
>
> I know it would be hard to find a sensible way to construct something in
> such a way that it could not have been evolved. Precisely because your
> bridge example is a known pitfall (and the paragraphs above therefore
> effectively a strawman argument). But simply the fact that you believe
> it is not possible does not mean you have in any way proven it to be so.
> Man and nature are often more inventive than either of them would have
> though.
Which then brings up Russel's Teapot. Its that a strawman argument, but
an accurate description of the problem. There is no logically
conceivable way that you can construct something in genetics where it
just appears, any more than with a bridge, so trying to find one that
did is like chasing invisible teapots. Its a useless pursuit of
something that you can't be 100% sure doesn't exist, but for which there
are lots, and lots, of evidence to suggest that its simply an
unnecessary complication to go hunting for it.
The first step, if you want to hunt for such a thing, is to come up with
a plausible description of what, and where, it will be found. Given a
few thousands years, some idiot is bound to find a teapot (if for no
other reason that that by then some other idiot will have accidentally
left one in an airlock, before someone else went EVA). By the same
token, if some clown keeps hunting long enough, they are bound to find
something "designed", but not because DNA was designed, but because
someone actually inserts some designed DNA in someone/something, then
dies, or something, without telling anyone.
Its the only conceivable condition where you can spend your time looking
for the genetic equivalent of Bigfoot, and actually find something that
isn't a man in a gorilla suit.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:20:23
Message: <4db1ff27$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 14:00, Nekar Xenos wrote:
> unambiguous?
>
http://www.google.co.za/search?client=opera&rls=en&q=ambiguous+quran&sourceid=opera&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8
Perhaps "ambiguous" was a poor choice of word compared to "contradictory".
I was really referring to Jim's quote "the one that says 'kill the infidels'
or the one that says 'Islam is peaceful'."
The answer is "whichever comes later."
One may reasonably be confused about what something unclear means, but one
cannot be reasonably confused about which instructions are applicable and
which aren't. Unlike, say, the Bible, where some people think what Paul (and
later popes) wrote supersedes what Jesus said, and others don't.
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:20:45
Message: <4db1ff3d$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 8:52 AM, Darren New wrote:
>> No, just to the point where it is in principle provable, but in practice
>> not.
>
> But nobody has even come up with an idea of how you would show a protein
> could not have evolved. "Irreducible complexity" doesn't show a protein
> could not have evolved. So how would you recognize such a protein?
>
They have tried math that claims its unlikely, if you 1) get the math
wrong, 2) make a lot of assumptions from the start, and 3) presumes you
have less time to do it that was actually available. Its the lotto
ticket hypothesis. I.e., one person's odds of winning at 1:6 billion is
stupidly low, so it should be somehow equally improbable for 100 million
people, attempting it twice a week, for an entirely unspecified length
of time, to do it either. In reality, people manage to win it almost
every time tickets are sold. In short, their *entire* argument hedges on
the odds of a solution happening with *one* attempt, in *one* step,
within *one* organism, instead of in like 900 trillion gazillion
attempts, with similar numbers of individuals, over multiple steps.
Its about as honest an attempt to describe why "Irreducible Complexity"
is even a valid concept as it would be if they included the joke math,
where you are made to prove that X = Y, by dividing by zero at some
point in the process. There only other hole card is the whole
"ontological depth" thing, which is just more hand waving. The principle
behind it being, "If we have a coherent description of what this was,
and how to measure it, it would amount to, 'Wow, this is X times more
complex that that other thing, thus Y times less likely to happen, in
the same, one step, single organism, single attempt case IC claims had
to happen for evolution to work.'"
Its one of the ironies of the whole idiot mess that evolution says, "You
don't just get things popping up out of no place, it happens slowly, in
all cases.", yet the central themes of ID/Creationism are that things
*do* just pop into existence, without any precursors, in DNA, but that
somehow this disallows rabbits hatching out of chicken eggs, while, at
the same time *claiming* that this is exactly what evolution proposes.
The stupid thing being, one would think that under the, "god did it!",
hypothesis, this is precisely how entire species would have had to
happen. lol
Even their claims about what evolution says (but doesn't), and therefor
ID, are incoherent with respect to their own argument about how you get,
say parrots, if the only birds on their stupid boat had been doves.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:23:01
Message: <4db1ffc5$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 15:03, Patrick Elliott wrote:
> Its the only conceivable condition where you can spend your time looking for
> the genetic equivalent of Bigfoot, and actually find something that isn't a
> man in a gorilla suit.
Except, in that case, it *is* precisely a man in a gorilla suit. Humans
tinkering with DNA are no more unnatural than beavers building dams. The
only way you'd actually be justified in teaching that anything discovered by
evolution is in doubt is if there was a *supernatural* source. Aliens
visiting and modifying the DNA doesn't mean the DNA didn't evolve. Not even
large black rectangular aliens.
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:32:24
Message: <4db201f8$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/20/2011 10:09 PM, Jim Henderson wrote:
> On Wed, 20 Apr 2011 16:08:25 -0700, Patrick Elliott wrote:
>
>> No it can't. Not in science.
>
> I didn't say "in science". In common usage, and that's part of the
> problem with the Creationist argument (which I stated before): They
> misuse the word "Theory".
>
> Now, if you couple the idea that ID is not science but evolution is, you
> can use "theory" in describing both - because one has the context of not
> being science, and one has the context of being science.
>
> It is a legitimate *linguistic* usage of the word. My point was to
> illustrate that this is the device used by creationists to argue that
> it's science, and it's born out of ignorance of the *scientific* usage of
> the word as compared to the 'common usage' use of the word - or it's born
> out of malicious use of the same word intended to cause confusion in
> those who don't understand that words can actually mean more than one
> thing, and that the *context* is important.
>
> Jim
Ok, lets put it another way.. Fag may be a legitimate word to be used to
describe a cigarette in some places, but using it a lot in the context
of a gay right rally, because you flat out fail to grasp what the
difference is, is probably a bloody stupid idea.
So, sure, using the layman's "theory" might be legitimate, its ***not***
legitimate if the thing being discussed is scientific evidence, since
doing so is not going to help you find out which is which, any more than
running around San Francisco during a pride parade yelling, "Anyone have
a fag?", is going to get you a tobacco product.
As someone that cares about the distinction, and this goes for most of
the people "in science", I don't give a flying frak what the "layman's"
definition is. Its allowing that definition to go unopposed that creates
everything from sympathy for Anti-vaxers, to climate change denialism,
to, "Its not creationism, honest!" 'teaching the controversy' nonsense.
If any fool can claim *anything* they pull out of their ass is a
"theory", how do you expect anyone to know the difference between the two?
Definitions matter. And, if the definition that is undermining good
sense is a problem, the solution isn't to shrug your shoulders and go,
"Ah, well, they use the word differently." No, the solution is to make
it clear that the murky gibberish version used by the public is *not*
the correct definition of the word, and more to the point, get
politicians, news agencies, and other people, where ever possible, to
stop bloody using it interchangeably with, "I pulled this out of my ass
this morning."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:42:02
Message: <4db2043a$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/21/2011 3:30 PM, Warp wrote:
> In principle, if they succed, it could not only sabotage the teaching
> of evolution, abiogenesis and even cosmology, but could possibly cause
> a chain reaction with all kinds of other fields of science. After all,
> if one pseudoscientific hypothesis is taught at schools in order to "teach
> the controversy", what stops other pseudoscientific hypotheses from doing
> the same? Perhaps homeopaths, faith healers, anti-vaccination people and
> germ theory denialists will start demanding to "teach the controversy" to
> medical students, holocaust denialists and conspiracy theorists will start
> demanding to "teach the controversy" in history class, flat earthers will
> start demanding to "teach the controversy" in geography class, and so on.
>
Too late, some colleges have "alternative medicine" programs in place,
as additions to the existing medical education (or, in a few cases, as a
different curriculum, where they decided to just make money printing
diplomas, instead of the almost as lame, "People seem to like it, so
lets sell it!", BS which has led to it sneaking in at other places.
Mind, you could also look at some so called colleges, like Liberty U,
which don't even make a pretense at teaching *anything* useful too.
Not too sure about geology, unless you include "the flood produced the
Grand Canyon", which I am sure Liberty U teaches, but.. revisionist
history in the US is only "revisionist", when you contradict the
existing mangled history that they made up to explain what happened in
each state (hint, you get a different version of even things like the
Civil War, depending on if you are in a few southern states, versus...
every other state...)
In short, this BS is already happening. And, as I stated upthread, part
of the problem is a general refusal to reject certain redefinitions of
terms, or properly explain why they are invalid definitions, such that
we have no word other than theory in science to describe theories, but
90% of the people in the country think the word means, "I pulled this
out of my ass to explain something."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:47:51
Message: <4db20597$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 12:05 PM, Jim Henderson wrote:
> On Thu, 21 Apr 2011 18:30:19 -0400, Warp wrote:
>
>> Jim Henderson<nos### [at] nospam com> wrote:
>>> I was thinking of something else (but of course I can't remember what
>>> now). You are correct that ID does try to pretend to be - I guess I'm
>>> having a problem with "scientific" being combined with "religious
>>> belief" and that's what led me to say "anti-scientific" - as I see
>>> 'religious belief' as being antithetical to 'knowledge'.
>>
>> The whole idea with the "intelligent design" movement is to mask the
>> fact that it's simply repackaged creationism, by removing all mentions
>> of "God" and other theistic claims.
>
> Yes, but a rebranding of creationism as "intelligent design" doesn't mean
> it's not religiously motivated. I guess for those who don't see through
> that deception and who have a very limited understanding of what
> scientific discovery actually is might think it was 'an appearance of
> science'.
>
>> In the worst case scenario the whole schooling system could get
>> sabotaged
>> to a catastrophical point. Science, technology and progress would suffer
>> enormously.
>
> Yes, and I think ultimately this demonstrates the real danger of this
> type of theistic thinking - not to mention that when it enters the public
> schools, it violates the establishment clause of the US Constitution. If
> a public school is teaching religious theology about the creation of the
> universe (whether they use religious metaphors or not), I'm sorry, that's
> state-sponsored religion, and that's unconstitutional.
>
> Jim
Strictly speaking, its only a violation if it only covers "one" creation
theory, from a single religion. The problem is: a) there is no way in
hell they would allow other creation theories. b) they would play the
same idiot game as they do in government, if allowed, which is to say,
"Since we don't have any X people here, we are only going to address the
creation beliefs of the people that actually are in the class." In
government this argument goes, "Since we couldn't find any priests from
other religions, we decided to just go with the Jesus ones." c) a lot of
them would ignore the requirement anyway, and only teach the Bible's
version, figuring that, since everyone there is Christian, they can get
by with it, without anyone suing them (also a common city government
tactic for this sort of BS, and even already in some schools, where they
teach creationism as right anyway, and only teach evolution as much as
needed to "look" like they tried, on a government test).
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Nekar Xenos
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:49:18
Message: <op.vuc20dcuufxv4h@xena>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 00:20:21 +0200, Darren New <dne### [at] san rr com> wrote:
> On 4/22/2011 14:00, Nekar Xenos wrote:
>> unambiguous?
>>
http://www.google.co.za/search?client=opera&rls=en&q=ambiguous+quran&sourceid=opera&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8
>
> Perhaps "ambiguous" was a poor choice of word compared to
> "contradictory".
>
> I was really referring to Jim's quote "the one that says 'kill the
> infidels' or the one that says 'Islam is peaceful'."
>
> The answer is "whichever comes later."
Oh, sorry about that.
>
> One may reasonably be confused about what something unclear means, but
> one cannot be reasonably confused about which instructions are
> applicable and which aren't. Unlike, say, the Bible, where some people
> think what Paul (and later popes) wrote supersedes what Jesus said, and
> others don't.
>
It's all Point Of View...
--
-Nekar Xenos-
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 18:58:45
Message: <4db20825$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 3:22 PM, Darren New wrote:
> On 4/22/2011 15:03, Patrick Elliott wrote:
>> Its the only conceivable condition where you can spend your time
>> looking for
>> the genetic equivalent of Bigfoot, and actually find something that
>> isn't a
>> man in a gorilla suit.
>
> Except, in that case, it *is* precisely a man in a gorilla suit. Humans
> tinkering with DNA are no more unnatural than beavers building dams. The
> only way you'd actually be justified in teaching that anything
> discovered by evolution is in doubt is if there was a *supernatural*
> source. Aliens visiting and modifying the DNA doesn't mean the DNA
> didn't evolve. Not even large black rectangular aliens.
>
True enough. Which is why the hard core ID people have pretty much
dropped the, "It could have been aliens.", thing. Well, except when
badly backed into a corner, where most will either admit they mean god,
but hedge that it, "might have been something else", without saying
what, or just can't come up with anything else any more, even to hedge
and hand wave the question away.
The game is pretty much up, except among people that haven't been paying
real attention, much like how there where still morons siding with SCO,
right up until the dead end, because they couldn't grasp how lost the
cause was, and how fact free, and unsupportable, their claims where.
Odds are, in ten years, a majority of people with accept that ID was
creationism all along, and nearly everyone, if they even remember, will
understand that SCO didn't have a case to start with, but there will
*still* be idiots defending the idea that *both* might have turned out
differently. lol
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 22 Apr 2011 19:09:50
Message: <4db20abe$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 3:49 PM, Nekar Xenos wrote:
>> One may reasonably be confused about what something unclear means, but
>> one cannot be reasonably confused about which instructions are
>> applicable and which aren't. Unlike, say, the Bible, where some people
>> think what Paul (and later popes) wrote supersedes what Jesus said,
>> and others don't.
>>
>
> It's all Point Of View...
>
Hmm. Maybe its just my liberal bias showing, but one commentator put it
like this, "You are entitled to your own opinion, but not your own
facts." Unfortunately, among the religious, they often make up facts,
based on their desired opinion. Something that can be seen every time
you deal with arguments about everything from evidence for a real Jesus,
to even things like, "god helps those that help themselves". Which, I
understand may have been first stated "officially" by Joan of Arc,
according to translation of the notes taken by her personal secretary,
but which was probably a common fiction even before she stated it.
Point Of View = "Putting a bag over your head, with a picture drawn on
it, because you don't like the existing view out your real window." ;)
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 01:03:15
Message: <4db25d93$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Fri, 22 Apr 2011 15:32:11 -0700, Patrick Elliott wrote:
> So, sure, using the layman's "theory" might be legitimate, its ***not***
> legitimate if the thing being discussed is scientific evidence, since
> doing so is not going to help you find out which is which
Except that we're talking about laypeople talking about science - people
who *think* they're using the term correctly. People who are *convinced*
they know what they're talking about.
People who *believe* that there is only one meaning for the word.
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 01:05:30
Message: <4db25e1a$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Fri, 22 Apr 2011 15:47:38 -0700, Patrick Elliott wrote:
> Strictly speaking, its only a violation if it only covers "one" creation
> theory, from a single religion.
If they're doing a comparative religions course, sure. Not if they're
calling it 'science'. Another case of laypeople using a term in a way
that is not appropriate.
> The problem is: a) there is no way in
> hell they would allow other creation theories. b) they would play the
> same idiot game as they do in government, if allowed, which is to say,
> "Since we don't have any X people here, we are only going to address the
> creation beliefs of the people that actually are in the class."
Which would be total BS, because it's not a religious studies course,
it's a science course, in which case, the topic under discussion is
scientific fact, not "nobody believes the FSM created the world or that
the world exists on the back of a giant turtle, so we won't discuss that."
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Orchid XP v8
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 06:36:44
Message: <4db2abbc$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 22/04/2011 06:08 PM, John VanSickle wrote:
> That's not hard. Read the Bible and see what it says about how to become
> a Christian, and what it commands Christians to do. Then compare it to
> the doings of the religious bodies in question. Time and again, at so
> many points of teaching, we find things taught and practiced that cannot
> be found in the Bible, from even the very basics of becoming a
> Christian, to the organization of the church, liturgy, and so forth.
"Heh, well, it *does* say in the Bible 'God helps those who help
themselves'."
"Actually... nuh, it doesn't. That's Beed's Chronicles. The Bible says
quite the opposite, in fact..."
--
http://blog.orphi.me.uk/
http://www.zazzle.com/MathematicalOrchid*
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Orchid XP v8
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 06:39:47
Message: <4db2ac73$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 21/04/2011 11:30 PM, Warp wrote:
> The whole idea with the "intelligent design" movement is to mask the
> fact that it's simply repackaged creationism, by removing all mentions
> of "God" and other theistic claims. In other words, ID attempts to be
> a "legit" scientific objection to the currently established hypotheses
> and theories on the formation of the universe, life and its diversity.
> The idea is to try to circumvent the annoying limitation in the US
> that theism and creationism cannot be taught as part of science, by
> simply maskerading it. Of course they aren't fooling anybody.
If only that final statement were true...
> In the worst case scenario the whole schooling system could get sabotaged
> to a catastrophical point. Science, technology and progress would suffer
> enormously.
Hopefully the damage would be limited only to America. Hopefully... :-.
--
http://blog.orphi.me.uk/
http://www.zazzle.com/MathematicalOrchid*
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 12:44:44
Message: <4db301fc$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/23/2011 3:39, Orchid XP v8 wrote:
> Hopefully the damage would be limited only to America. Hopefully... :-.
Maybe if we screw up everyone's science here enough, we won't have enough
smart people to build the weapons we tend to use to invade foreign countries.
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Orchid XP v8
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 13:44:56
Message: <4db31018@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 23/04/2011 05:44 PM, Darren New wrote:
> Maybe if we screw up everyone's science here enough, we won't have
> enough smart people to build the weapons we tend to use to invade
> foreign countries.
Perhaps. But I doubt it. :-S
OG claims that he used to be in the UK's armed forces, in their signals
division, working with classified cryptography and such. He told us how
the UK has one way running the entire telecomms truck, while the USA
army has basically one guy for every individual piece of equipment, and
each guy only knows how to operate that one item of kit, and basically
has no clue WTF it does or why it's important. They just know how to set
it up and fix it if it breaks. Apparently they were blown away that in
the UK one person can understand more than one thing.
Then again, this is the same OG who tells us that all Americans are
dicks. And the same OG who claims to have designed classified military
hardware that he can't tell us about becuase them he'd have to kill us,
but at the same time seems to be ignorant of basic cryptographic
principles, so.......
--
http://blog.orphi.me.uk/
http://www.zazzle.com/MathematicalOrchid*
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 14:05:22
Message: <4db314e2$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 10:03 PM, Jim Henderson wrote:
> On Fri, 22 Apr 2011 15:32:11 -0700, Patrick Elliott wrote:
>
>> So, sure, using the layman's "theory" might be legitimate, its ***not***
>> legitimate if the thing being discussed is scientific evidence, since
>> doing so is not going to help you find out which is which
>
> Except that we're talking about laypeople talking about science - people
> who *think* they're using the term correctly. People who are *convinced*
> they know what they're talking about.
>
> People who *believe* that there is only one meaning for the word.
>
> Jim
And, it would be just so "strident", or something, to point out that the
world is no in fact flat to such people... lol
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Patrick Elliott
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 14:11:59
Message: <4db3166f$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/22/2011 10:05 PM, Jim Henderson wrote:
> On Fri, 22 Apr 2011 15:47:38 -0700, Patrick Elliott wrote:
>
>> Strictly speaking, its only a violation if it only covers "one" creation
>> theory, from a single religion.
>
> If they're doing a comparative religions course, sure. Not if they're
> calling it 'science'. Another case of laypeople using a term in a way
> that is not appropriate.
>
Yes, well.. The only people on their side really "calling" it science
also tend to think praying over your kid, who is bleeding to death
internally, constitutes "science" too, since you know, in the Babble,
doing that heals people. Most of the people pushing for ID to be used as
an alternative are not making that argument. The argument they are
making is, "I don't know a damn thing about the science, so I am going
to assume there isn't anything too it, and if their isn't, I don't see
why my mythology shouldn't trump secular mythology." They very clearly
think this is an argument between whether or not Yahweh or Darwin
created the world in 6 days. In short, its ignorance trying to replace
knowledge, because the people involved think a 2,000 year old copy of
Grimm's Fairy Tales is, being old, a better description of what is going
on than 200 years of people taking the thing apart and figuring out how
it actually does.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 14:32:09
Message: <4db31b29$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=2223#comic
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: andrel
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 15:22:47
Message: <4DB32706.3050301@gmail.com>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 23-4-2011 0:03, Patrick Elliott wrote:
> On 4/21/2011 3:35 PM, andrel wrote:
>>> ID's central premise, sadly, is that it just "poofed" into being. Hell,
>>> even the ones arguing "front loading", fail to grasp that any such
>>> "master genetic code", to avoid breaking the organism fatally, while
>>> inserting new features, has to take clear steps, in which it replaces
>>> parts of the system, only as possible, before reaching and end result.
>>
>> I know it would be hard to find a sensible way to construct something in
>> such a way that it could not have been evolved. Precisely because your
>> bridge example is a known pitfall (and the paragraphs above therefore
>> effectively a strawman argument). But simply the fact that you believe
>> it is not possible does not mean you have in any way proven it to be so.
>> Man and nature are often more inventive than either of them would have
>> though.
>
> Which then brings up Russel's Teapot. Its that a strawman argument, but
> an accurate description of the problem. There is no logically
> conceivable way that you can construct something in genetics where it
> just appears, any more than with a bridge, so trying to find one that
> did is like chasing invisible teapots. Its a useless pursuit of
> something that you can't be 100% sure doesn't exist, but for which there
> are lots, and lots, of evidence to suggest that its simply an
> unnecessary complication to go hunting for it.
>
> The first step, if you want to hunt for such a thing, is to come up with
> a plausible description of what, and where, it will be found. Given a
> few thousands years, some idiot is bound to find a teapot (if for no
> other reason that that by then some other idiot will have accidentally
> left one in an airlock, before someone else went EVA). By the same
> token, if some clown keeps hunting long enough, they are bound to find
> something "designed", but not because DNA was designed, but because
> someone actually inserts some designed DNA in someone/something, then
> dies, or something, without telling anyone.
>
> Its the only conceivable condition where you can spend your time looking
> for the genetic equivalent of Bigfoot, and actually find something that
> isn't a man in a gorilla suit.
The problem here is that every argument you use assumes that everything
evolved in a natural way. If you assume that (or even if you know that
it is a fact,) then everything is entirely clear. But it all falls apart
if you start from the other assumption.
Somewhere in my library is a book I inherited from my father. It gives a
number of arguments that proof that God does exist. Very convincing,...
if you believe God does exist. I found most of them amusing and/or
interesting but none was convincing.
So unless you have a proof of evolution that convinces even the die hard
creationists then we better leave it at that. You don't have to convince me.
--
Apparently you can afford your own dictator for less than 10 cents per
citizen per day.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Nekar Xenos
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 15:24:38
Message: <op.vuen69bxufxv4h@xena>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 01:09:37 +0200, Patrick Elliott <sel### [at] npgcable com>
wrote:
> On 4/22/2011 3:49 PM, Nekar Xenos wrote:
>>> One may reasonably be confused about what something unclear means, but
>>> one cannot be reasonably confused about which instructions are
>>> applicable and which aren't. Unlike, say, the Bible, where some people
>>> think what Paul (and later popes) wrote supersedes what Jesus said,
>>> and others don't.
>>>
>>
>> It's all Point Of View...
Just a little tongue in the cheeck off-off-topic playing with words...
>>
> Hmm. Maybe its just my liberal bias showing, but one commentator put it
> like this, "You are entitled to your own opinion, but not your own
> facts." Unfortunately, among the religious, they often make up facts,
> based on their desired opinion. Something that can be seen every time
> you deal with arguments about everything from evidence for a real Jesus,
> to even things like, "god helps those that help themselves". Which, I
> understand may have been first stated "officially" by Joan of Arc,
> according to translation of the notes taken by her personal secretary,
> but which was probably a common fiction even before she stated it.
>
> Point Of View = "Putting a bag over your head, with a picture drawn on
> it, because you don't like the existing view out your real window." ;)
I couldn't agree with you more. Some say that there is no such thing as
truth - each person has his own reality. I wonder how that would stand in
court...
--
-Nekar Xenos-
"The spoon is not real"
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 15:46:20
Message: <4db32c8c$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 11:05:09 -0700, Patrick Elliott wrote:
> And, it would be just so "strident", or something, to point out that the
> world is no in fact flat to such people... lol
I have to admit that I agree with Dawkins about how strange it is that we
afford religion some kind of 'special protection' from questioning when
we don't afford the same protection to other topics.
If I tell you that the world is flat, you can scientifically dispute that
(and prove that I'm wrong) and everything's fine. If I tell you that my
religious holy book says that the world is flat, though, then somehow
it's offensive to argue with me about that.
It's quite ridiculous.
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 15:47:24
Message: <4db32ccc$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 21:22:46 +0200, andrel wrote:
> So unless you have a proof of evolution that convinces even the die hard
> creationists then we better leave it at that.
No matter what proof is there, the die-hard creationists will reject it
because it means abandoning their belief.
That's the problem.
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: andrel
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 15:50:19
Message: <4DB32D7A.90506@gmail.com>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
PS: now listening to a life radio broadcast of the St Matthew Passion.
That I don't believe in a God does not prevent me from appreciating the
music of those who did.
--
Apparently you can afford your own dictator for less than 10 cents per
citizen per day.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: andrel
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 16:07:03
Message: <4DB33165.3000800@gmail.com>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 23-4-2011 21:47, Jim Henderson wrote:
> On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 21:22:46 +0200, andrel wrote:
>
>> So unless you have a proof of evolution that convinces even the die hard
>> creationists then we better leave it at that.
>
> No matter what proof is there, the die-hard creationists will reject it
> because it means abandoning their belief.
That is the evolutionists interpretation. They will actually reject it
because they know some of the assumptions are wrong.
> That's the problem.
Not really. Or at least not a bigger problem than trying to convince me
God does exist.
It only becomes a problem when they try to prevent teaching real science
and research.
--
Apparently you can afford your own dictator for less than 10 cents per
citizen per day.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 16:20:47
Message: <4db3349f@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 22:07:01 +0200, andrel wrote:
> On 23-4-2011 21:47, Jim Henderson wrote:
>> On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 21:22:46 +0200, andrel wrote:
>>
>>> So unless you have a proof of evolution that convinces even the die
>>> hard creationists then we better leave it at that.
>>
>> No matter what proof is there, the die-hard creationists will reject it
>> because it means abandoning their belief.
>
> That is the evolutionists interpretation. They will actually reject it
> because they know some of the assumptions are wrong.
Because they *believe* some of the assumptions are "wrong". Like the
"assumption" that there is no creator. Since that flies in the face of
their belief that there is a God, they reject it because "it can't
possibly be right that there is no God."
>> That's the problem.
>
> Not really. Or at least not a bigger problem than trying to convince me
> God does exist.
I think there's a fundamental difference, if you're like most of the
atheists I know - you're willing to be convinced given sufficient
evidence. But such evidence doesn't exist.
Compare the creationists view - they're not willing to be convinced there
is no creator. The only thing that works for them is if the question of
whether or not their is a creator is taken off the table.
> It only becomes a problem when they try to prevent teaching real science
> and research.
I disagree, it becomes a problem because they teach kids (who are still
developing the ability to think rationally) that there is no value in
thinking rationally about a problem - that you can just 'believe your
way' through a situation.
That undermines not only teaching real science, but the ability for
students to think about problems in a rational way.
There's a reason why US students view themselves as more confident than
students in other parts of the world - they're taught to believe in
themselves, regardless of how well they do with 'facts'. Hence, low
scores on exams, but high confidence.
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 16:21:48
Message: <4db334dc@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 21:50:18 +0200, andrel wrote:
> PS: now listening to a life radio broadcast of the St Matthew Passion.
> That I don't believe in a God does not prevent me from appreciating the
> music of those who did.
Absolutely not, and that's not the point of the discussion. I appreciate
a lot of music written by believers (remember, I trained as a classical
violinist). That doesn't mean I have to believe in the fairy tale. ;)
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 17:05:01
Message: <4db33efd@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/23/2011 12:46, Jim Henderson wrote:
> It's quite ridiculous.
Probably due to a long history of killing people who argued with the
authority in charge.
Just like in the USA, I can say Obama is a wrinkle-bottomed poopy-pants, and
in China I'd probably at least get beaten up if not imprisoned.
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: andrel
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 17:45:06
Message: <4DB34860.20800@gmail.com>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 23-4-2011 22:20, Jim Henderson wrote:
> On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 22:07:01 +0200, andrel wrote:
>
>> On 23-4-2011 21:47, Jim Henderson wrote:
>>> On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 21:22:46 +0200, andrel wrote:
>>>
>>>> So unless you have a proof of evolution that convinces even the die
>>>> hard creationists then we better leave it at that.
>>>
>>> No matter what proof is there, the die-hard creationists will reject it
>>> because it means abandoning their belief.
>>
>> That is the evolutionists interpretation. They will actually reject it
>> because they know some of the assumptions are wrong.
>
> Because they *believe* some of the assumptions are "wrong". Like the
> "assumption" that there is no creator. Since that flies in the face of
> their belief that there is a God, they reject it because "it can't
> possibly be right that there is no God."
>
>>> That's the problem.
>>
>> Not really. Or at least not a bigger problem than trying to convince me
>> God does exist.
>
> I think there's a fundamental difference, if you're like most of the
> atheists I know - you're willing to be convinced given sufficient
> evidence.
No, I am not, that is the point. There being a God is to such an extend
contradictory to being me, that I will never accept any evidence(, hence
my reference to that book of my father). I think you will find that true
for other atheists as well.
> But such evidence doesn't exist.
>
> Compare the creationists view - they're not willing to be convinced there
> is no creator. The only thing that works for them is if the question of
> whether or not their is a creator is taken off the table.
I don't think that there is too much difference in attitude between them
and me. Other than that I understand the world and they don't. So I am
defending the truth and they a fallacy.
>> It only becomes a problem when they try to prevent teaching real science
>> and research.
>
> I disagree, it becomes a problem because they teach kids (who are still
> developing the ability to think rationally) that there is no value in
> thinking rationally about a problem - that you can just 'believe your
> way' through a situation.
That is sort of what I meant too.
> That undermines not only teaching real science, but the ability for
> students to think about problems in a rational way.
Are Americans worse programmers than Japanese?
> There's a reason why US students view themselves as more confident than
> students in other parts of the world - they're taught to believe in
> themselves, regardless of how well they do with 'facts'. Hence, low
> scores on exams, but high confidence.
--
Apparently you can afford your own dictator for less than 10 cents per
citizen per day.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: andrel
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 17:47:48
Message: <4DB34902.9060805@gmail.com>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 23-4-2011 22:21, Jim Henderson wrote:
> On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 21:50:18 +0200, andrel wrote:
>
>> PS: now listening to a life radio broadcast of the St Matthew Passion.
>> That I don't believe in a God does not prevent me from appreciating the
>> music of those who did.
>
> Absolutely not, and that's not the point of the discussion. I appreciate
> a lot of music written by believers (remember, I trained as a classical
> violinist).
No I don't remember. (and have forgotten you mentioned it probably by
tomorrow.)
> That doesn't mean I have to believe in the fairy queen. ;)
--
Apparently you can afford your own dictator for less than 10 cents per
citizen per day.
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Darren New
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 21:28:59
Message: <4db37cdb$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On 4/23/2011 14:45, andrel wrote:
> I think you will find that true for other atheists as well.
For some of them, I imagine. I'm willing to believe in a creator if shown
sufficient evidence.
Interestingly, every faithful person I've asked has said that if God Himself
came to them and told them they were wrong, they wouldn't believe it.
--
Darren New, San Diego CA, USA (PST)
"Coding without comments is like
driving without turn signals."
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Alain
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 23 Apr 2011 22:47:48
Message: <4db38f54$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
Le 2011/04/23 15:24, Nekar Xenos a écrit :
Some say that there is no such thing as
> truth - each person has his own reality. I wonder how that would stand
> in court...
>
Are you talking of "truth" or "Truth" ot "truths"?
Search your own Truth and admire those who search for it, but be
extremely wary of anybody who say he have the Truth.
Alain
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 24 Apr 2011 01:05:10
Message: <4db3af86@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 14:04:57 -0700, Darren New wrote:
> On 4/23/2011 12:46, Jim Henderson wrote:
>> It's quite ridiculous.
>
> Probably due to a long history of killing people who argued with the
> authority in charge.
Well, I don't know about that - in the US we have frequent disagreements
and arguments about various things, ranging from politics to American
Idol <barf>. Sometimes quite intense at that.
But when it comes to religion, there is a very strong veneer of "oooh,
don't even go there! You're questioning someone's *beliefs*" that's just
weird.
> Just like in the USA, I can say Obama is a wrinkle-bottomed poopy-pants,
> and in China I'd probably at least get beaten up if not imprisoned.
Sure, but that's different than when it comes to religion.
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 24 Apr 2011 01:09:11
Message: <4db3b077@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 23:45:04 +0200, andrel wrote:
>> I think there's a fundamental difference, if you're like most of the
>> atheists I know - you're willing to be convinced given sufficient
>> evidence.
>
> No, I am not, that is the point. There being a God is to such an extend
> contradictory to being me, that I will never accept any evidence(, hence
> my reference to that book of my father). I think you will find that true
> for other atheists as well.
That is different - so you're saying that if someone presented rational
evidence for a God, you wouldn't accept it? I find that *highly* unusual.
>> But such evidence doesn't exist.
>>
>> Compare the creationists view - they're not willing to be convinced
>> there is no creator. The only thing that works for them is if the
>> question of whether or not their is a creator is taken off the table.
>
> I don't think that there is too much difference in attitude between them
> and me. Other than that I understand the world and they don't. So I am
> defending the truth and they a fallacy.
Then you're arguably just as religious as they are. Otherwise, you'd
have to be open to a rational explanation or evidence for God. For me, I
don't see it today, but if credible evidence were presented, I wouldn't
just look away from it and say "no, that cannot be". That doesn't mean
I'd accept it unchallenged, either, though.
>>> It only becomes a problem when they try to prevent teaching real
>>> science and research.
>>
>> I disagree, it becomes a problem because they teach kids (who are still
>> developing the ability to think rationally) that there is no value in
>> thinking rationally about a problem - that you can just 'believe your
>> way' through a situation.
>
> That is sort of what I meant too.
Then on that we agree. :)
>> That undermines not only teaching real science, but the ability for
>> students to think about problems in a rational way.
>
> Are Americans worse programmers than Japanese?
I have no data to support one being better than the other. Do you?
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
From: Jim Henderson
Subject: Re: A kind of revolution is happening in the United States
Date: 24 Apr 2011 01:09:35
Message: <4db3b08f$1@news.povray.org>
|
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
On Sat, 23 Apr 2011 18:28:54 -0700, Darren New wrote:
> On 4/23/2011 14:45, andrel wrote:
>> I think you will find that true for other atheists as well.
>
> For some of them, I imagine. I'm willing to believe in a creator if
> shown sufficient evidence.
>
> Interestingly, every faithful person I've asked has said that if God
> Himself came to them and told them they were wrong, they wouldn't
> believe it.
Nice paradox. ;)
Jim
Post a reply to this message
|
 |
|  |
|  |
|
 |
|
 |
|  |
|
 |