POV-Ray : Newsgroups : povray.general : Upcoming major hardware upgrade - what to choose for POVing? Server Time
24 Nov 2024 16:28:08 EST (-0500)
  Upcoming major hardware upgrade - what to choose for POVing? (Message 1 to 3 of 3)  
From: Jörg "Yadgar" Bleimann
Subject: Upcoming major hardware upgrade - what to choose for POVing?
Date: 8 Mar 2018 15:18:01
Message: <5aa19a79$1@news.povray.org>
Hi(gh)!

With an ageing AMD FX-6200 hexa-core crashing every few hours, I'm 
contemplating a major hardware upgrade! Possibly, the crashes result 
just from a power supply too weak (450 watts) for my recently installed 
new graphics adapter (Nvidia Geforce GTX 1050 Ti), then the issue could 
be fixed for less than 100 euros. If mainboard and/or CPU are wrecked, 
it might be somewhat more expensive (an AM3+ socket mainboard plus a 
slightly faster hexacore CPU - an AMD FX-6350 clocking at 3.9 GHz would 
be about 180 euros, with the flawlessly working DDR4-1333 RAM bars still 
being usable). However, as my loved one is ready to spend even more 
money for my computer upgrade, I really would like to how to get the 
highest POV-Ray performance per euro and/or per watt of power 
consumption... are there any reliable benchmark lists for current CPUs?

I've seen those Intel 2600s socket board capable of managing up to 128 
GiB of RAM (which would give Khyberspace and POVEarth a serious 
boost!)...and matching 18-core high end CPUs (which probably would be 
too expensive even for Micha), and running such a beast would really be 
tempting... but how fast are they really?

See you in Khyberspace!

Yadgar


Post a reply to this message

From: Alain
Subject: Re: Upcoming major hardware upgrade - what to choose for POVing?
Date: 8 Mar 2018 16:04:42
Message: <5aa1a56a@news.povray.org>
Le 18-03-08 à 15:18, Jörg "Yadgar" Bleimann a écrit :
> Hi(gh)!
> 
> With an ageing AMD FX-6200 hexa-core crashing every few hours, I'm 
> contemplating a major hardware upgrade! Possibly, the crashes result 
> just from a power supply too weak (450 watts) for my recently installed 
> new graphics adapter (Nvidia Geforce GTX 1050 Ti), then the issue could 
> be fixed for less than 100 euros. If mainboard and/or CPU are wrecked, 
> it might be somewhat more expensive (an AM3+ socket mainboard plus a 
> slightly faster hexacore CPU - an AMD FX-6350 clocking at 3.9 GHz would 
> be about 180 euros, with the flawlessly working DDR4-1333 RAM bars still 
> being usable). However, as my loved one is ready to spend even more 
> money for my computer upgrade, I really would like to how to get the 
> highest POV-Ray performance per euro and/or per watt of power 
> consumption... are there any reliable benchmark lists for current CPUs?
> 
> I've seen those Intel 2600s socket board capable of managing up to 128 
> GiB of RAM (which would give Khyberspace and POVEarth a serious 
> boost!)...and matching 18-core high end CPUs (which probably would be 
> too expensive even for Micha), and running such a beast would really be 
> tempting... but how fast are they really?
> 
> See you in Khyberspace!
> 
> Yadgar

A 450w PSU looks like a little weak for a modern computer. If the PSU is 
under rated, it's currents and voltages become erratic, leading to 
crashes. Try something in the 600-750w range.
A rule of thumb is that the PSU should be rated to about twice the 
actual power consumption of the computer for optimum effecienci and 
stability.

If you go the way of a totally new computer, then, for POV-Ray, you have 
those considerations :
Video card : NOT important at all -> Take some entry level offering.
CPU : It does all the work. Aim high ! Larger instructions cache is a plus.
RAM : As much as you can afford. If possible, choose the lowest latency 
that you can find. Long burst length is normally not a factor as most 
access if for relatively small, randomly located, data chunks.
Drives : SSDs will make you save on the electric bil side, but cost 
more. HDs are beter to store huge amounts of data that don't need to be 
accessed very quickly, like most media files, but they consume more 
electricity.
Monitor : Need a good quality one.
PSU : Need to be over rated to ensure stability.
Don't forget a good cooling.


Alain


Post a reply to this message

From: Kenneth
Subject: Re: Upcoming major hardware upgrade - what to choose for POVing?
Date: 9 Mar 2018 12:50:01
Message: <web.5aa2c88fc995fb11a47873e10@news.povray.org>
=?UTF-8?Q?J=c3=b6rg_=22Yadgar=22_Bleimann?= <yaz### [at] gmxde> wrote:
> Hi(gh)!
>
> With an ageing AMD FX-6200 hexa-core crashing every few hours, I'm
> contemplating a major hardware upgrade! Possibly, the crashes result
> just from a power supply...

From my own limited experience-- with a crashed WinXP computer last year-- I
would suspect the power supply as being the cause. Which might then damage the
motherboard, if the PS really screws up. In my case, the motherboard got fried
when the PS failed catastrophically. (A cheap OEM power supply, no doubt.)

I'm no expert with this stuff, though.


Post a reply to this message

Copyright 2003-2023 Persistence of Vision Raytracer Pty. Ltd.