POV-Ray : Newsgroups : povray.binaries.images : A puzzling problem Server Time
3 Jul 2024 01:37:38 EDT (-0400)
  A puzzling problem (Message 1 to 3 of 3)  
From: Anthony D  Baye
Subject: A puzzling problem
Date: 7 Nov 2014 04:10:01
Message: <web.545c8b88c39bf0e1538d4890@news.povray.org>
I was going to wait to debut this until I'd gotten the finished product done,
but I could use a second (or third/fourth/etc..) set of eyes on the problem.

The problem is an aperiodic tiling with sixfold symmetry, and it almost works,
but suddenly fails at anything more than 3 levels deep.

the following snippet is from geometry.pov, and I believe this is where the
problem is:
        push(array[3] { t1[1] + baseVec*baseLen/3, t1[0], t1[1] })
        push(array[3] { t1[0],
                        t1[1] + baseVec*baseLen/3,
                        t1[2] - baseVec*baseLen/3 })
        push(array[3] { t1[1] + baseVec*2*baseLen/3, t1[0], t1[2] })

if I comment out the second push operation, the ugliness goes away, but no more
equilateral triangles are introduced and the pattern has large (if interesting)
gaps in it.

I would appreciate it if anyone could help me with this.

sorry about the messy code.  The image shows the pattern at 3 levels deep.

Regards,
A.D.B.

// BEGIN stack.inc
#include "math.inc"
#include "arrays.inc"

#version 3.7;

//#declare STACKDEBUG = 0;
#declare maxStack = 50;
#declare stackPointer = 0;
#declare stackSize = 0;

#declare STACK = array[maxStack]

#macro push(item)
    #if(stackSize > 0)
        #declare stackPointer = stackPointer + 1;   // First, increment
stackPointer.

        // if the stack is full, double the capacity.
        // like an array-based hash, except we don't need to worry about
collisions.
        #if(stackPointer = maxStack)
            #declare maxStack = maxStack * 2;
            Resize_Array(STACK, maxStack)
        #end
    #end

    #declare STACK[stackPointer] = item;
    #declare stackSize = stackSize + 1;

#end

#macro pop(receiver)
    #if(stackSize > 0)
        #ifdef(STACKDEBUG)
            #debug concat("stackPointer: ", str(stackPointer, 1, 0), "\n")
            #debug concat("maxStack:", str(maxStack, 1, 0), "\n")
            #debug concat("stackSize: ", str(stackSize, 1, 0), "\n")
        #end
        #local temp = STACK[stackPointer];          // grab the top item
        #if(stackPointer > 0)
            #declare stackPointer = stackPointer - 1;   // decrement
stackPointer
        #end

        // if the stack is less than a quarter full, but maxStack is greater
than 50,
        // halve the size.
        #if(maxStack > 50 & stackPointer < maxStack * 0.25)
            #declare maxStack = maxStack / 2;
            Resize_Array(STACK, maxStack)
        #end
        #declare stackSize = stackSize - 1;

        #declare receiver = temp;
    #end
#end

#macro top(receiver)
    #if(stackSize != 0)
        #declare receiver = STACK[stackPointer];
    #end
#end

#macro isEmpty()
    #if(stackSize = 0)
        #local return = true;
    #else
        #local return = false;
    #end
    return
#end
// END stack.inc

// BEGIN geometry.pov
#version 3.7;

#include "math.inc"
#include "colors.inc"
#include "stack.inc"

global_settings {
    assumed_gamma 1.0
    }

light_source { <0.0, 20.0, 0.0>  rgb 1 }
camera {
    perspective
    location <0.0, 20.0, 0.0>
    up y
    right x*(image_width/image_height)
    look_at 0
    }

#default { pigment { rgb <0.08, 0.375, 0.75> } }

prism {
    linear_spline
    -0.25, 0.0, 7
#for(a,0,360,60)
    10.0*<cosd(a), sind(a)>
#end
    }

#declare triangles = array[6]

//#for(T,0,360,60)
//    cylinder { 3.0*<cosd(T), 0.0, sind(T)> 3.0*<cosd(T+60), 0.0, sind(T+60)>
0.03125 pigment { Orange } }
//    cylinder { 3.0*<cosd(T), 0.0, sind(T)> 0.0 0.03125 pigment { Orange } }
//#end

#local T = 0;
#while(T < 360)
    push(array[3] { <0.0, 0.0, 0.0> , 10.0*<cosd(T), 0.0, sind(T)>,
10.0*<cosd(T+60), 0.0, sind(T+60)> })
//    #declare triangles[ceil(T/72)] = array[3] { <0.0, 0.0, 0.0> ,
3.0*<cosd(T), 0.0, sind(T)>, 3.0*<cosd(T+60), 0.0, sind(T+60)> }
#local T = T + 60;
#end
#declare t1 = <0,0,0>;
//#for(Z,0,5,1)
//#declare t1 = triangles[Z]
//pop(t1)
#macro subdivide(T1)
#declare v1 = T1[1] - T1[0];
#declare v2 = T1[2] - T1[0];

#declare T = acos(vdot(vnormalize(v1),vnormalize(v2)));
#declare xOff = acos(vdot(vnormalize(v1),<1,0,0>));
#declare sideLen = vlength(v1);
#declare bVec = sideLen*<cos(xOff + T/2), 0, sin(xOff + T/2)>;
#declare centroid = <(T1[0].x + v1.x + v2.x)/3,
                    (T1[0].y + v1.y + v2.y)/3,
                    (T1[0].z + v1.z + v2.z)/3>;
#local Area = abs(
                    (
                    T1[0].x*(T1[1].z - T1[2].z) +
                    T1[1].x*(T1[2].z - T1[0].z) +
                    T1[2].x*(T1[0].z - T1[1].z)
                    ) / 2
                   );
//#declare centroid2 = t1[0] + vnormalize(bVec)*(sideLen/(2*cos(T/2)));

#debug concat ("T: ", str(degrees(T), 1, 6), "\n")
#debug concat ("xOff: ", str(xOff, 1, 6), "\n")
//#debug concat ("Area: ", str(Area, 1, 12), "\n")
//cos(Alpha) = B/C ==> B = C*cos(Alpha) ==> C = B/cos(Alpha)
//sphere { t1[0] + bVec/2, 0.03125 pigment { Orange } }
//#if(Area > 3)
    #if(degrees(T) = 60)
        #debug "Type: 1\n"
        push(array[3] { centroid , T1[1], T1[0] })
        push(array[3] { centroid , T1[2], T1[0] })
        push(array[3] { centroid , T1[1], T1[2] })
    #else
        #local baseVec = vnormalize(T1[2] - T1[1]);
        #local baseLen = vlength(T1[2] - T1[1]);
        #debug "Type: 2\n"
        #debug concat("baseVec: " vstr(3, t1[2]-t1[1], ", ", 1, 12) "\n")
        #debug concat("baseLen: " str(baseLen, 1, 12) "\n")
        // !!!!!!!!!! I believe the problem is here !!!!!!!!!!!!
        push(array[3] { t1[1] + baseVec*baseLen/3, t1[0], t1[1] })
        push(array[3] { t1[0], t1[1] + baseVec*baseLen/3, t1[2] -
baseVec*baseLen/3 })
        push(array[3] { t1[1] + baseVec*2*baseLen/3, t1[0], t1[2] })
    #end
#end

//pop(t1)
//subdivide(t1)
//pop(t1)
//subdivide(t1)
//pop(t1)
//subdivide(t1)
//#else
#while(!isEmpty())
//#for(p,0,8,1)  // for investigating the generation stepwise.
pop(t1)
#local Area =
abs(
    (
    t1[0].x*(t1[1].z - t1[2].z) +
    t1[1].x*(t1[2].z - t1[0].z) +
    t1[2].x*(t1[0].z - t1[1].z)
    ) / 2
   );
#debug concat ("Area: ", str(Area, 1, 12), "\n")
#if(Area > 5)
subdivide(t1)
#else
//    #debug concat("t1[1]: ", vstr(3, <t1[1].x, t1[1].y, t1[1].z>, ", ", 1, 6),
"\n")
//    #debug concat("t1[2]: ", vstr(3, <t1[2].x, t1[2].y, t1[2].z>, ", ", 1, 6),
"\n")
    sphere { t1[0] 0.0625 pigment { Blue } }
    cylinder { t1[0], t1[1], 0.015625 pigment { Red } }
    cylinder { t1[1], t1[2], 0.015625 pigment { Yellow } }
    cylinder { t1[2], t1[0], 0.015625 pigment { Red } }
#end
#end
// End geometry.pov


Post a reply to this message


Attachments:
Download 'geometry.png' (138 KB)

Preview of image 'geometry.png'
geometry.png


 

From: Bald Eagle
Subject: Re: A puzzling problem
Date: 7 Nov 2014 10:25:00
Message: <web.545ce417eb43a3ad5e7df57c0@news.povray.org>
"Anthony D. Baye" <Sha### [at] spamnomorehotmailcom> wrote:

> the following snippet is from geometry.pov, and I believe this is where the
> problem is:
>         push(array[3] { t1[1] + baseVec*baseLen/3, t1[0], t1[1] })
>         push(array[3] { t1[0],
>                         t1[1] + baseVec*baseLen/3,
>                         t1[2] - baseVec*baseLen/3 })
>         push(array[3] { t1[1] + baseVec*2*baseLen/3, t1[0], t1[2] })
>
> if I comment out the second push operation, the ugliness goes away,

What's a push operation? - I didn't see anything under arrays in the docs, and a
quick search in the help index didn't pull anything up.

All I can say is, that from my ignorant standpoint, I'd start with "Which one of
these 3 things doesn't look like the other 2".  The second push is the only one
with TWO mathematical operations.

I'd start by messing with that and passing values to a debug stream.


Post a reply to this message

From: Anthony D  Baye
Subject: Re: A puzzling problem
Date: 8 Nov 2014 02:00:10
Message: <web.545dbe90eb43a3ad1538d4890@news.povray.org>
Turns out that the problem was in my centroid calculation...

Regards,
A.D.B.


Post a reply to this message


Attachments:
Download 'geometry.png' (483 KB)

Preview of image 'geometry.png'
geometry.png


 

Copyright 2003-2023 Persistence of Vision Raytracer Pty. Ltd.