POV-Ray : Newsgroups : irtc.stills : Results are in....! : Re: Results are in....! Server Time: 26 Sep 2020 16:03:28 GMT
  Re: Results are in....!  
From: Mike Raiford
Date: 20 Jun 2006 13:10:09
St. wrote:

>      Is there a problem with using a modelling prog for the IRTC  instead of 
> CSG in PoV-Ray, Mike?  After all, the IRTC is not PoV-Ray related. I thought 
> that this was a -general- raytracing comp. where any modelling prog and 
> raytracer would be exceptable regardless of the raytracing program used?

Absolutely not! Some of the best images are done with modelers, and 
sometimes non-pov. The image in question was made with POV, I just don't 
see simply using a modeler as earning a technical merit award. Artistic 
merit? Yes. Top 3? Sure! Technical Merit? No way! There's nothing 
special about it. Unless they've demonstrated-- and it doesn't appear 
they have by looking at the description, which was rather terse-- some 
programming feat in Wings3D, such as some sort of customization to 
create their models, a script, their own utilities, an inventive process 
for creating the image. Anything. None of that was there. It was all 
ready made software, and hand made models (that does deserve artistic 
merit, the image *is* good, and does deserve to place.)

Unless I'm misunderstanding technical merit...


-- 
~Mike

Things! Billions of them!


Post a reply to this message

Copyright 2003-2008 Persistence of Vision Raytracer Pty. Ltd.