POV-Ray : Newsgroups : povray.beta-test : Same scene renders different in v3.7beta34 versus v3.62 : Re: Same scene renders different in v3.7beta34 versus v3.62 Server Time
5 Oct 2024 15:30:42 EDT (-0400)
  Re: Same scene renders different in v3.7beta34 versus v3.62  
From: Warp
Date: 23 Aug 2009 06:47:31
Message: <4a911e43@news.povray.org>
clipka <ano### [at] anonymousorg> wrote:
> Warp schrieb:
> > clipka <ano### [at] anonymousorg> wrote:
> >> In 3.6, however, the rgb 0.5 object (B) will look way darker: POV-Ray 
> >> will have output "127"
> > 
> >   You mean that POV-Ray 3.6 didn't gamma-correct the output at all, while
> > POV-Ray 3.7 now does?

> I mean that 3.6 didn't do it /by default/ (which is what you've been 
> asking about all the time).

> >   Does that mean there's now a new option to set the gamma correction of
> > the created image (the actual pixels, not just some header data in the
> > image file format)? Is there a way to turn this off, if one so desires
> > (eg. if you really *want* the pixels to be exactly (127,127,127) and
> > nothing else)?

> Yup. "File_Gamma" is the magic ini file option. Set it to 1.0 and you'll 
> get linear pixel values, plus (for PNG and HDR) a header saying that the 
> data is linear. Set it to 2.2 and you'll get gamma pre-corrected pixel 
> values, plus a header saying that the data is pre-corrected for a gamma 
> of 2.2. (The latter is highly recommended though, as not all viewers - 
> browsers included - support linear image data.)

> Note that this makes it impossible to deliberately mess with gamma for 
> artistic effect in POV-Ray when you use PNG output and all your image 
> processing software handles gAMA chunks properly: You can only affect 
> the encoding of pixels - and thereby the dynamic ranges of highlights 
> vs. shadows - but not their interpretation.

> At least that's the theory as known to me. I never tested in detail 
> whether it indeed works exactly as intended.

  Well, this clears things up a bit. I'm still not 100% happy that old
scenes will render differently by default, but I suppose it's an acceptable
change.

  I highly recommend writing a concise and clear explanation of this in the
"what's new in POV-Ray 3.7" section when the final version is published.
Else it's only going to cause a lot of confusion.

-- 
                                                          - Warp


Post a reply to this message

Copyright 2003-2023 Persistence of Vision Raytracer Pty. Ltd.