|
![](/i/fill.gif) |
On 17-5-2010 22:19, Patrick Elliott wrote:
> On 5/16/2010 1:10 PM, Darren New wrote:
>> Patrick Elliott wrote:
>>> If we had had patents back during the original colonies, or earlier,
>>
>> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent#History
>>
Typical example of WIME (Wikipedia Is Your Enemy). You are not supposed
to make claims that are factually wrong, not even jokingly, not even if
everybody understands what you mean :(
> Let me rephrase... If they had the kind of idiot patents we now see in
> Software, where you can make it stupidly vague, describe a set of
> instructions, rather than a physical thing, then sue everyone that even
> *sort of* does the same thing...
>
> Good example, from the video. You have two data sets. Say X1, X2, X3.
> One is liking pets, second is "affectionate", third is.. I don't know,
> favorite color = red. You also also have the same data from someone
> else, Y1, Y2, Y3. You then so a fairly uncomplicated comparison on them.
> Nope, no patent here. Now.. ***Name*** the variables, say, Zip, Zop, and
> Zap. Put out a patent that says, "Comparing Zip, Zop and Zap to find
> "compatibility" between individuals with those traits, and suddenly it
> **is** patentable. You named them after all, which, according to the
> argument that led to most of this BS, makes the process "unique", not
> just basic fracking boolean math on a matrix of values.
>
> This is how damn stupid things are right now. And, if you make it vague
> enough, you get some damn silly lawsuits, and people actually *winning*,
> or getting settlements, on the basis of such nonsense. You can't produce
> an inexpensive alternative to product X, if simply marketing it means
> you have to spent a million dollars to pay off all the people that show
> up to say, "Heh! We think that falls under out patents!"
>
> Its irrelevant that, at one time, patents actually worked. Since they
> didn't allow the kinds of patents, until ****very recently****, that we
> see in software.
>
Post a reply to this message
|
![](/i/fill.gif) |