> Nope. Probability theory gives zero.

OK, well I will have to bow down to your superior maths knowledge over mine. 
I was just going by what I had read about 1/infinity not being strictly 
speaking zero (only under certain circumstances) and the fact that the 
infinite series seems to be defined as always equal to 1 in mathematics.  I 
was not aware of anything specific in probability theory that defined the 
probability of choosing 1 item from an infinite number as zero.  Writing the 
probability as 1/infinity rather than zero explained the "never gets chosen" 
paradox you mentioned quite nicely, but oh well...

>> Of course you can discuss how this relates to reality, but I'd rather
>> not get involved in that one, it could an infinitely long time :-)
>
> But that *is* what Warp and I are complaining about.

You should first discuss if there is enough time for an infinite number of 
finite length events to ever happen :-)  Personally I think you have to 
treat this a strictly theoretical concept, otherwise you run into all sorts 
of other technicalities about whether it can actually happen.

Post a reply to this message