Fa3ien wrote:

>>    - Ranking will be in 3 categories
> 
> Seen Gille's latest post on the matter ?
> Seen the graphs ?
> 
> Why keep the voting process 3 times longer than necessary ?
> 
> Fabien.

Yes, I've seen the post and the graphs.  I thought carefully about the 
charts and the graphs.  Here's my problem:  Currently we have 6 awards - 
1st, 2nd, 3rd, Technical, Artistic and Concept.  Do we continue to give 
6 awards?  We can reduce to one ranking per picture if we drop the last 
3 awards. If you want to provide the last three (automated) awards, how 
do you propose we award them with only one rank?

In terms of voting time, I'll be using a star-rating control where you 
click on one of 10 stars to vote.  Since I'm proposing that we require 
voters to write a comment for each submission, typing the comments will 
take far longer than the voting itself.

Do you have a proposal on how many awards to give and how to calculate them?

I'm looking for constructive comments on the voting system.  Please, if 
you're going to criticize something I proposed please offer your version 
of an alternative.  As I said, I can't satisfy everyone and I'm doing my 
best to get public input while still keeping the spirit of the competition.

David

Post a reply to this message