Let me first say that the feedback is extremely valuable, and I like to
both give and get feedback.

> The level of interest has definitely dropped along with the
rankings....
> maybe the top 10 would be more workable.
I was away and wasn't able to respond to "my" post right away, I think a
lot of discussion died because of that..

> 1) Being on the POV newgroup may put off artists who are using other
> software.
True. As a POV user, I also feel I can give better feedback on POV
images.

> I personally like the idea Mark has here. I'm always particularly
interested
> in discussion of other artists creative process, the "why I did this"
> factor.
I always do a lot of thinking about the image, not just making a lot of
models and put them together. But there is always a lot of things you
haven't though about, which others do, I think that's great! Though it
feels a little weird to get a positive "WOW!!" response on something you
didn't even notice :-)

I suggest that the people that want response to their image can post an
thread about it. Then we'll only get discussion where the artist
participate, which I think is a good thing. Plus those who place lower
than top 20 could get some feedback too.

Just a thought..

-Peter

Post a reply to this message