"Tina" <you### [at] foadorg> wrote in message news:3ac08966@news.povray.org...

<SNIP>

I'm sorry you felt insulted by your scores - and looking at them, it may be
that some cross contamination took place on your concept score (i.e. the
voter's feelings about the technical and artistic merits of your pic
affected their voting on the concept score). It would have got at least a 10
from me, which is the minimum I give to any pic that's on-topic.

However, the scores on artistic and technical seem fair enough I'm afraid.

With regard to the comments, for myself, I score first and then comment on
pics in scoring order. I comment as many as I can before the deadline.

If you want to ensure that you receive comments on your work, post it here
prior to the comp., or solicit here for comments after the comp. is over.

Here are mine:

Apart from the sun, the textures are very grainy (what is the grail
reflecting? whatever it is, it doesn't look very nice).

IMHO, the pic seems cluttered and unfocused - it might be better if you
dropped the other objects apart from the grail, and dropped the egg as well.

The planet at the right is clipped too much by the edge of the picture.

Is there any AA on this? It seems very jaggy, particularily the edge of the
sun.

Post a reply to this message