"Josh English" <eng### [at] spiritonecom> wrote in message
news:3A0### [at] spiritonecom...
> If it is a clear contrast, I don't see why not. Of course, I'm not an
expert in
> this. All I know is that I will need ot maintain an open mind when voting
this
> round. I usually get harsh with "Concept" and I haven't found a good way
to vote
> that section well.
>

My latest voting system works like this:

concept 0-9 =  % off-topic in varying degrees
concept 10 = on-topic 100%
concept 20 = defines the topic

I then use this percentage as a multiplier for the other scores. So an image
that gets 5 for concept, being largely off topic, will only get 50% of the
scores I would have awarded in art and technical for an on-topic image of
the same quality. Any image getting 10 or greater for topic gets the full
100% of marks in art and technical.

In other words, scores less than 10 in topic will have a detrimental effect
on my scores for the other catagories. Scores 10 or greater do not affect my
scoring for other catagories.

Post a reply to this message