POV-Ray : Newsgroups : irtc.stills : Dec results (comment) : Dec results (comment) Server Time
23 Dec 2024 11:55:17 EST (-0500)
  Dec results (comment)  
From: Dan Connelly
Date: 16 Jan 1999 08:44:57
Message: <36A097DA.D63730A8@flash.net>
The results (top 10) :

Image        AMerit   TMerit   CMerit    Overall
========     ======   ======   ======    =======
strike       16.068   17.386   14.955    16.1364
ac_vs_eb     14.600   14.889   14.711    14.7333
afrog        15.378   14.911   13.222    14.5037
fmenc        14.023   13.750   14.068    13.9470
8_forgiv     14.867   13.911   12.711    13.8296
spider       14.822   14.267   12.356    13.8148
13kitty      12.682   14.932   12.750    13.4545
tbenc01      13.578   14.089   12.667    13.4444
food101      12.467   12.378   13.978    12.9407
stonegod     12.886   12.818   12.727    12.8106

====================================================

I find this very interesting....

The votes on strike.jpg are curious.

I gave it 18-20-13, so clearly artistically and technically I thought it 
was a top image.  I had tbenc01.jpg @ 18-19-14, the two being tied
for the top score.

The thing I don't understand is how the "concept,originality"
of strike.jpg was the top of all the images entered.... there 
were certainly more novel interpretations of "first encounter".

Cross-"contamination" of voting categories, perhaps?


Dan


-- 
http://www.flash.net/~djconnel/


Post a reply to this message

Copyright 2003-2023 Persistence of Vision Raytracer Pty. Ltd.