On 4/24/2016 2:06 AM, Christian Froeschlin wrote:
> On 22.04.2016 13:51, Stephen wrote:
>
>> We would not mind comments and suggestions
>
> Some random thoughts on this
>
> - Of course, try it, why not
>

No reason not to. I wanted to see what the reaction would be and if 
there were any suggestions.

> - The short topics may need to be interpreted more literally
>    than usual in order for them to make sense in the long topic.
>    Releasing all topics at once could give a bit more flexibility
>

It would indeed and easier to plan your series.

> - The short topics should be self-contained so that anyone can
>    participate in a single topic only as time allows. It might be
>    good to encourage complete scenes over "object test renders".
>

That's the problem I can see if you know what the final topic will be.

[Homage to McGonagall] ;)


> - Since participating in the complete set is a longer commitment
>    it might make most sense to split up Challenge 1.

I am not too sure that I follow you.

> Alternatively
>    use a future Challenge 1 topic that incorporates elements from
>    earlier Challenge 2 topics.
>

This is what I had been thinking of. Maybe incorporating elements from 
two of the previous three short (Challenge 2) topics.

-- 

Regards
     Stephen

Post a reply to this message