POV-Ray : Newsgroups : povray.binaries.images : US Brig Niagara WIP Server Time
14 Nov 2024 22:23:23 EST (-0500)
  US Brig Niagara WIP (Message 1 to 8 of 8)  
From: Merrin
Subject: US Brig Niagara WIP
Date: 16 Oct 2003 20:32:11
Message: <3f8f388b@news.povray.org>
I ahve never been happy with my use of Bezier Patches for sales on this
project. So, I have given the MechSim feature from MegaPov a try. The large
sail in the center of the image was created using MechSim and SDL...without
UV mapping. While it still needs plenty of work, I am pleased with the
results so far. I welcome your feedback and suggestions for improvements.

The flag was made with the cloth sim feature also found in Megapatch using
UV mapping.


Post a reply to this message


Attachments:
Download 'USS Niagara 3.jpg' (31 KB)

Preview of image 'USS Niagara 3.jpg'
USS Niagara 3.jpg


 

From: Marc Jacquier
Subject: Re: US Brig Niagara WIP
Date: 17 Oct 2003 03:40:28
Message: <3f8f9cec@news.povray.org>
Wow great!
so you got bezier patches for sale? lol what's the price?
No sorry just kidding ;-)
I understand why tou are not happy with bezier: you mechsim sail is vry
realistic, it looks like a heavy cloth sail in a light breeze
while bezier sail looks like an elastic cloth light sail.
The flag is great  too.
you are doing a long but impressive job with this boat!
Now you want suggestion: If your ship sails following wind as the flag
shows, is it normal that the Royal sail is hauled taut this way?.
I never skipped that sort of  rig but it seems to me that is should be
released (don't know the right word)
Marc

3f8f388b@news.povray.org...
> I ahve never been happy with my use of Bezier Patches for sales on this
> project. So, I have given the MechSim feature from MegaPov a try. The
large
> sail in the center of the image was created using MechSim and
SDL...without
> UV mapping. While it still needs plenty of work, I am pleased with the
> results so far. I welcome your feedback and suggestions for improvements.
>
> The flag was made with the cloth sim feature also found in Megapatch using
> UV mapping.
>
>
>


Post a reply to this message

From: Tim McMurdo
Subject: Re: US Brig Niagara WIP
Date: 17 Oct 2003 04:10:01
Message: <web.3f8fa3a99f57b1a99a303f820@news.povray.org>
Marc Jacquier wrote:
>Wow great!
>so you got bezier patches for sale? lol what's the price?

Er... Sail! I have never won any awards for my typing or spelling!

>>Now you want suggestion: If your ship sails following wind as the flag
>shows, is it normal that the Royal sail is hauled taut this way?.
>I never skipped that sort of  rig but it seems to me that is should be
>released (don't know the right word)

Thank you very much for your comments. Here is where my ignorance shows
through. I have never sailed & this shows. Let me see if I have this right.
The flag and the large topsail show the wind blowing from aft while the
Spanker sail (the one the flag is attached to) is rigged fore and aft.
Should this sail be rotated so that it is pointing abeam of the ship? Say
rotate it 45 or 60 degrees to port?


Post a reply to this message

From: Abe
Subject: Re: US Brig Niagara WIP
Date: 17 Oct 2003 07:25:00
Message: <web.3f8fd0979f57b1a9759ecd850@news.povray.org>
Merrin wrote:
>I ahve never been happy with my use of Bezier Patches for sales on this
>project. So, I have given the MechSim feature from MegaPov a try. The large
>sail in the center of the image was created using MechSim and SDL...without
>UV mapping. While it still needs plenty of work, I am pleased with the
>results so far. I welcome your feedback and suggestions for improvements.
>
>The flag was made with the cloth sim feature also found in Megapatch using
>UV mapping.
>

oooh, I'm really liking this!

At the risk of pointing out what is probably obvious to you, here are my
suggestions.
Technical - I don't see any braces, sheets or lifts. On the sail (which is
GREAT) I'm wanting to see chafe marks, esp. where it can rub up against the
stays. Also, are there any staysails rigged on this thing? If so (and
not raised) there should be a halyard flopping around with the stays.

Artistic - I almost want to ask if the direct sunlight should be a little
more yellow - is the sun angle low enough the justify it? It would go well
with the spot of red provided by the flag. And, now that you've done so
much work on the sail geometry, consider a translucent "texture" for your
final render. If you do this, it will free the sails from being earthbound
and really make them fly!

Abe


Post a reply to this message

From: Marc Jacquier
Subject: Re: US Brig Niagara WIP
Date: 17 Oct 2003 15:20:39
Message: <3f904107@news.povray.org>

web.3f8fa3a99f57b1a99a303f820@news.povray.org...
> The flag and the large topsail show the wind blowing from aft while the
> Spanker sail (the one the flag is attached to) is rigged fore and aft.
> Should this sail be rotated so that it is pointing abeam of the ship? Say
> rotate it 45 or 60 degrees to port?

I'd rotate it  about 60 degrees yes. but still not sure how this king of
rigging is exploited

Marc


Post a reply to this message

From: Alain
Subject: Re: US Brig Niagara WIP
Date: 17 Oct 2003 16:23:02
Message: <Xns9417A6A55622FCaelum@204.213.191.226>
"Merrin" <jod### [at] wohrrcom> wrote in news:3f8f388b@news.povray.org:

> [...]
> The large sail in the center of the image was created using MechSim
> [...]

Wow, nice sail!  Looks great.


Post a reply to this message

From: Tim McMurdo
Subject: Re: US Brig Niagara WIP
Date: 17 Oct 2003 16:35:01
Message: <web.3f90521b9f57b1a9297c858d0@news.povray.org>
Marc Jacquier wrote:
>Wow great!

Thank you very much.

>so you got bezier patches for sale? lol what's the price?

I have never won any awards for spelling or typing!

>Now you want suggestion: If your ship sails following wind as the flag
>shows, is it normal that the Royal sail is hauled taut this way?.
>I never skipped that sort of  rig but it seems to me that is should be
>released (don't know the right word)

I believe you are referring to the spanker sail? (The sail with the flag
attached to it?) If so, I agree with what you have pointed out. The sail
does indeed need to be rotated so that it realistically catches the wind. I
will make this simple change right away. I believe I should rotate it to
port.

Thanks for your generpous comments and tip.

Tim


Post a reply to this message

From: Tim McMurdo
Subject: Re: US Brig Niagara WIP
Date: 17 Oct 2003 16:40:01
Message: <web.3f90536a9f57b1a9297c858d0@news.povray.org>
Abe wrote:

>At the risk of pointing out what is probably obvious to you, here are my
>suggestions.
>Technical - I don't see any braces, sheets or lifts. On the sail (which is
>GREAT) I'm wanting to see chafe marks, esp. where it can rub up against the
>stays. Also, are there any staysails rigged on this thing? If so (and
>not raised) there should be a halyard flopping around with the stays.

I agree that all of these details are needed and they are present ont he
plans I am following. The chafe marks will require some thinking on my part
as I do not want to use UV mapping if I can avoid it (Point of pride).


>Artistic - I almost want to ask if the direct sunlight should be a little
>more yellow - is the sun angle low enough the justify it? It would go well
>with the spot of red provided by the flag. And, now that you've done so
>much work on the sail geometry, consider a translucent "texture" for your
>final render. If you do this, it will free the sails from being earthbound
>and really make them fly!

I will make changes to the sun light as I am currently using white. I seem
to remember a thread around here giving rgb values for sunlight. I'll
search for that one.

I'm not sure that old canvas sails were translucent like modern sail cloth.
Does anybody know? I would make this change if I can confirm that they were
indeed translucent.

All of your comments are helpful and encouraging. Thanks for taking the time
to push me along in the right direction.

Tim


Post a reply to this message

Copyright 2003-2023 Persistence of Vision Raytracer Pty. Ltd.